Jinnah Often Came to our House : – ‘And look how that turned out!’

jinnah-often-came-to-our-house

3.5/5 Stars Goodreads Rating System

“Those whom the gods wish to destroy they first make mad.” ~Ancient Proverb

The irony is, that this proverb is used by Jinnah’s character in the book. ‘Muhammad Ali Jinnah‘ to my mind, is undoubtedly, the most controversial figure in the Indian freedom struggle. An unorthodox well educated Muslim barrister from London, who driven by ambition single-handedly changed the fate of the Indian subcontinent, by doing the very thing that he had opposed for most of his political career, until the fated 1937 Indian provincial elections .i.e inciting communal tensions between Hindus and Muslims, and thus, becoming the poster boy for the British policy of ‘Divide & Rule’.

Kiran Doshi has earned my respect, by seamlessly joining History and Fiction in his second published novel ‘Jinnah Often Came to our House’. One of the most difficult task for any Historical fiction writer would be to create anticipation in the story, people already know what happened, so to make them curious and WANT to know and feel surprised would be quite a feat. He has achieved this by keeping the story centralized to Bombay and to the leaders directly involved with it, Jinnah (Obviously) and Gandhi (to some extent, because the story of Jinnah would never be complete without The Mahatma). Also from his own admission by not thinking ahead and letting the story develop. The result is a 663 page(Kindle edition) long magnum opus. Though one thing is to be noted, that this is in no way a comprehensive work on Jinnah’s life, rather this story provides a common man’s perspective of the man and the time. This is something which, admittedly, bothered me in the beginning, but, then i realized was actually worthwhile, these people (Gandhi, Nehru, Jinnah, etc.) are now Legends, they have gained (or if not will gain in a few decades) the status of TITANS among men, where every word that they have ever said would be treated as Gold and their criticism by anyone as outright blasphemy. So, now, almost 70 years since independence seeing them as human, capable of everything that ails a normal person, struggling and faltering , indecisive and proud is almost a reminder that  “If there is a single quality that is shared by all great men, it is vanity” (~Yousuf Karsh). And how true!, if only the Congress had realized that sooner, if only Jinnah was given his desired pound of flesh, if only his ego was soothed and massaged, if only Nehru or Gandhi would not have sidelined him and implored him to stay as the bridge between Congress and the league, if only Jinnah himself could have realized that what he was starting would lead to the creation of such unprecedented hate that it could last centuries, if only,if only, if only, ahhhh…We would be living in a completely different world.

But no, we can learn but never alter History. The story follows the ‘Kowaishi’ family in Bombay from 1903 till 1948, it Starts with the eldest son of the family ‘Sultan’ returning from London after completing his law studies, marrying ‘Rehana’ his beautiful and well educated impressionable wife and joining the Bombay high court as a barrister, much like Jinnah and then finally meeting the man in flesh. And from there it adapts to all that has to come, adding a whole lot of drama in between taking input from the social norms, beliefs and stereotypes of that time period. Bombay in the 1900’s would have been quite a place, i was transported to it, actively imagining it through the author’s writing and experience. The effect of the freedom struggle from ‘Gokhale‘ to ‘Tilak‘ to ‘Jinnah‘ to ‘Gandhi‘ on the common masses was an interesting touch. How the people perceived the struggle, their doubts, hopes from these leaders were something to wonder about. The story gives you everything it promises in its description, at time i felt that the story dragged a bit, that maybe near the end it focused more on the family drama than on the effect of Jinnah or the freedom struggle on the tale. But the characters never became redundant, in its style and length it reminded me of ‘Karambhoomi‘ though the two books are completely different in essence, the tale of sacrifice and transformation was the common denominator. Mr. Doshi has in my opinion done a great job on the book, the story though sometimes becoming dull was never truly boring, though a lengthy tale, the time period i suppose, demanded it’s share of words, the story had to react to so much.

The only complaint i have are the last chapters, they seemed rushed, and if the intention was to induce a sense of urgency in the reader well then it felt more irritating than exciting. And the complete biasness against the newly formed state’s administration, though in most of the novel Mr.Doshi had used fiction to blunt the wounds of history, but in the last few chapters the directness was like an open handed slap to the face. Which was surprising for me as i expected him to keep the whole story blunt till the end, him being a diplomat and all. This novel, told a story of a people divided and how that division came to be, what started it, The partition of Bengal?,  The separate electorates policy?, The Muslim Royals like Aga khan ?, The indifference and self surety of IN Congress?, Jinnah?. Lessons each and lessons all, i see the current political state of India and am horrified to see that we have yet to learn a lot of them still. Perhaps this fictional tale would help. Perhaps we should be mindful of the lessons, because as George Santayana famously wrote “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it”. And Its about time!.

The Slow Regard of Silent Things

slowregard

3/5 Stars Goodreads Rating System

This story is for all the slightly broken people out there. I am one of you. You are not alone. You are all beautiful to me.” ~Patrick Rothfuss

Now wait a god damn minute…you were not supposed to say that damn it, that was supposed to be implicit, an unsaid understood thing, now you have labeled us for the world. Why!! Don’t you know we like the obscurity?, of-course you do, you aptly named the story “The Slow Regard of Silent Things” for crying out loud,… damn you Patrick.

This is not a novel, it is not a continuation of The Kingkiller Chronicle  saga, so of-course some people would be disappointed, on that account i am too, the wait i assure you IS slowly BUT surely killing me too. But Mr.Rothfuss has been upfront about this, you won’t understand this if you have not read his previous works, even if you have you can probably live without this. He has given ample opportunities to people for backing off. And to be honest i could have lived without the “Author’s Endnote” you had no reason to defend this Mr.Rothfuss.

Now,on with the extended ‘Character study’, because, lets be honest that’s what it is. And just to clarify, it’s BRILLIANT. ‘Auri’ had intrigued me ever since she was introduced in the tale of ‘KVOTHE’, she was mysterious, sweet, silent, brooding, completely bonkers and full of life. Well at the end of this little story she remains all that (still ‘mysterious’ to my utter annoyance, so many unanswered questions). This story depicts a week in Auri’s life, it doesn’t give away her past, neither her future, nor her many many mysteries ,but what it does is, it gives you a look inside her head, how she perceives things, how she thinks, functions, decides, judges, lives. And to know all that about someone as special a character as Auri is very rewarding. It has been 4 years since i read ‘The Wise Man’s Fear’ so to get back into that world took some pages, and revisiting the summary of the previous books but after that this little jaunty story was a treat. I was fully prepared to not like it, but i just couldn’t help but love it. When you start to empathize with a character like Auri, when her little conversations with inanimate objects start to make sense to you, her thinking and ‘way of things’ seem beautiful to you then one of two things are happening either you have completely lost your marbles (i mean to be fascinated by the story of a loner mad little girl,really..) or something in you has truly resonated with her life (NOT i tell you a flattering experience), in any case after reading it you look in the mirror and say “Shit!”.

The story is written with a single minded focus on Auri, and her world alone, all the side plots of Kingkiller Chronicles are mute and void in her world, the whole of the 104 pages(Kindle edition) are dedicated to her and her ‘way of things’, its beautiful in a way, frustrating in another but pure somehow, innocent. We have come to enjoy fantasy for its immense and impossible complexities, its dark or hilarious aspects of plots and characters ,in that regard this was completely different. People expecting another awesome tale like that of ‘KVOTHE’ would perhaps find this boring. But Auri is not Kvothe , she is uniquely Auri. And though i expect that in the final book of the series we might finally have all the jigsaw puzzles about Auri’s life. This was a welcome addition to her tale.

I liked this story but i am somehow unable to explain why properly, so maybe i will just end this with another quote from the book which might be as true for this little story then for what it was originally meant for

To be so lovely and so lost. To be all answerable with all that knowing trapped inside. To be beautiful and broken.”

 

 

 

CHOICES :- INDIA at the World’s Big Round Table.

choices

3.5/5 Goodreads Rating System

“There is some self-interest behind every friendship. There is no friendship without self-interests. This is a bitter truth.” ~Chanakya.

This is perhaps more true for Diplomacy than for anything else. One of the best things about this book other than its core theme was it’s author, there is no one better to tell you about the Choices India made in her most diplomatically charged phase, than the diplomat who helped her make them.

Mr.Menon had been personally involved in all the 4 issues discussed in this book(China in the 1990s, USA in 2006, Pakistan & 26/11, Sri Lanka & LTTE in 2009) and has many years of experience driving the foreign policy of India.Hence this book was a delight and an immediate priority for me to read, to know from the people directly responsible the What and Whys is really refreshing. Though he has been quite evasive on the “How” part, the intricate details of the negotiations or the MOM that i had hoped this might contain are absent. Nevertheless the book though lacking in detailed blow by blow of the various issues, gives you the reasoning and thought process behind the various actions taken by the Indian government working within the constraints of that time period.

One of the most important things this book made me realize is how underappreciated some of the very critical events are, for example P.V. Narasima Rao (9th Prime Minister of India) & his border peace and tranquility agreement with China. The 1990’s was a very critical time for India, our economy was at its lowest point and we were in an unprecedented danger of being bankrupt (Courtesy of the ‘License Raj’ that had been practiced in the country till then) ,so naturally the immediate priority was the economy and its liberalization, but to achieve this having stability with our immediate neighbors was a necessary prerequisite. More so with China, having been defeated in the 1962 war, India was acutely aware of the scale of disaster that could ensue if the Chinese decided to press their advantage once again. Settling the border issue or in the lack of a favorable settlement, agreeing on a peaceful process for its resolution was paramount. Adding to that China,being the victor, would be very difficult to negotiate with specially resisting any kind of concessions(not every country could be as magnanimous (or foolish) in victory as we were after 1971 during the Shimla agreement), and to top it all off convincing the current political heads of the country to shake hands with a previous foe would have been quite a challenge. Yet,the deal was done. And its importance barely noticed,the mind boggles.

Lao Tzu said “A leader is best when people barely know he exists, when his work is done, his aim fulfilled they will say: we did it ourselves”. This quote is quite apt for the “Accidental” Prime Minister Manmohan Singh & his civil nuclear agreement with the USA in  2006. Like every Indian i have my own misgivings about Mr. Singh and his tenure but the 123 agreement is one of the master strokes that has to be attributed to his dogged persistence. Convincing a country like the USA which scuttled a previous agreement for nuclear fuel supply, imposed sanctions on India after the “Pokharan” nuclear test in 1974, to a civil nuclear agreement, making it alter its own laws and giving a ‘Clean’ exemption from the very restrictions by the NSG that were a direct result of India’s nuclear program in the first place would have been a daunting task. But yet again the deal was done,it is quite interesting to know how,and Mr.Menon as our faithful guide do not disappoint. Yet, i felt that he was way too soft on Mr.Singh, which is understandable as he was his National Security Adviser at the time.But still, not taking a strong military action against Pakistan after 26/11, and just posturing on the border and using diplomacy, still, to this day, doesn’t sit well with me, maybe because as a citizen having these kind of  opinions is easy as opposed to being the one taking the decisions, but explaining away as to why we didn’t use something like Israel’s strong covert response to the situation “because we are different” and “that approach would only lead to temporary peace and not solve the main issue” is ludicrous. Mr.Menon himself admits that he suggested a strong and clear response, which he says we are fortunate the PM didn’t go for, i mean ‘War’ was maybe not the ideal answer but we could have taken the scum who planed 26/11 out, morality be damned. But again, a country’s foreign political machinery is too complicated a thing to be always in perfect working order. He warns the situation is different now and the restraint of the past is now just that ‘Past’.

The Lankan civil war and our involvement in it is once again, i felt, was downplayed quite a bit in the book, India made a number of blunders regarding the LTTE, and i agree with Mr.Menon that perhaps due to our meddling and trying to broker peace we prolonged Sri Lankans suffering. Though, i feel a complete disarmament of the rebels should have been a prerequisite condition before any kind of negotiation. But it is always easy to judge history. The assassination of PM Rajiv Gandhi, is perhaps the result of said blunders and the cause which finally lead to the war’s bloody conclusion.

The last 2 chapters of the book are perhaps my favorite, India’s nuclear policy and a ‘final word’ about the intricacies of decision making, diplomacy and negotiation and their broad contemplation on the country’s psyche and its unique personality were very well crafted. Here in the last chapters you really get to see the diplomat in Mr.Menon in all his glory. The book overall is well thought and well presented, the author talks about things he knows and has a first hand experience in, adding credibility to his statements and thoughts. The fact that these agreements and issues were in a volatile time, as Mr.Menon notes where one could maneuver, concede and negotiate successfully ,as opposed to now where the world order is much more cemented and diplomats don’t have the leeway that they previously enjoyed is what makes the book and his own experience so important. I have always had a keen interest in nations and their behavior towards each other. To any such enthusiast and or history buff this book is a treat, perhaps we would not agree on all the points that Mr.Menon makes but that is not the purpose of this book. He lays down his views and experiences, and as Confucius said “Study the past if you would define the future”. There are indeed lessons here, and lessons worth reading.

MOSSAD: – साम-दाम-दंड-भेद with Classic Jewish chutzpah

mossad

3/5 Stars , Goodreads Rating System

First off, Israel has always fascinated me,A country of just 8 million people (The city that i am currently in,Bangalore, has more than 10 million) has such potential, such innovative tech companies ,a well trained military and one of the most sophisticated and deadly secret service which is dubbed as “The most effective killing machine”.The Jewish people have had a very hard history, and they have learned a lot from it, from the pharaohs of Egypt to Hitler in Nazi Germany,they have survived the worst mankind had to offer. And they have emerged as hardened,wary people, for whom endurance, resistance and secrecy is not just a need but an established way of life.

MOSSAD, details a number of clandestine operations that have been conducted by the state of Israel since its inception . These operations include hunting Nazis for their war crimes in WW2 to rescue missions conducted to bring oppressed or troubled Jews to the promised land. Each operation and story is depicted in a fantastical way, the ops have been spiced up quite a bit in some of the stories but the fact that they did happen ,and broadly in the way as described is awe inspiring.One of the things that hit me was the sheer audacity of some of them. The old ‘Chanakya’s’ teaching of getting your way by

  • Saam: to advice and ask
  • Daam: to offer and buy
  • Dand: to punish
  • Bhed: exploiting the secrets

has been incorporated in MOSSAD’s DNA. Though the glorification of the agents and the agency is understandable, as the authors are Israeli and sympathetic to the Zionist nation. But the ease with which the MOSSAD was charged with assassinations, and the “anything goes” method that they have tried to get the job done ,unnerved me. It is a bit uneasy when you read about scientists being assassinated by letter bombs in which innocent bystanders get hurt or the prominent members of a country’s ruling class targeted for the safety of the Jewish nation, Or the eye for an eye vengeful operations being sanctioned by a country’s government against terrorists, traitors or even other nations. But perhaps in Israel’s world, surrounded by openly hostile enemy states on all sides, fighting an insurgency within its own walls and deterring powerful opponents like Iran, “anything goes” is the only way, perhaps  the phrase “Only the paranoid survives” fits the bill here.

The book is well researched, its timeline, its director after director depiction of the evolution of Mossad was interesting, the writers have taken some creative liberties to make the stories more life like ,making some seem like Hollywood spy thrillers, but this book is about the secret service so as they say “when in Rome…”.Though I could argue the moral point against many of the operations conducted, the point remains that they worked. The sheer will and stubborn loyalty of MOSSAD’s directors and agents to each other, and to their nation and its people is inspiring. 

I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the shadow world.To read about one of the most dangerous service in the world is always an eye opener.

BreakOut Nations :- because “Where else will the Money Go.”

breakout-nations

3.5 Stars out of 5

I so wish that i had read this book 3 years back, not only because the statistics and assumptions considered in the book would have been much more relevant, but also because this would have considerably helped me in my “Country Analysis” assignment, in the course of my Masters. Oh well, better late than never i Suppose.

Economics ,is a fascinating study, to which i got acquainted quite late in life but it turned out to be one of those things that you instantly like(Specially Macroeconomics) and are surprised by the fact that you didn’t come across them sooner. Ruchir Sharma has managed to do the impossible with Economics in this book, he has kept the brush strokes broad enough that a layman could understand and appreciate the overall picture & he has kept the same strokes fine enough in places so that an expert or enthusiast could really enjoy the process and take away some major points with them.

One of the worst and best things about reading Non-fiction is that it is a SLOW process, it HAS to be, there is no other way to do it, between readings you have to stop & digress, to let it sink in,do a little side research of your own,read some history ,some present news,relate and revel in the topic entirely. And on that account Breakout nations does a bang on job, Mr. Sharma has used a LOT of research in this book, he has discussed about almost every important Nation and Area on the globe.Giving you insights and a lot to think about. This book talks about Nations and their progress towards economic marvels, specially about the emerging nations and who among them will ‘Break out’ as the fastest & most durable in the race towards growth and prosperity. It does so ,by systematically analyzing one emerging nation at a time.As it is a non fiction,we don’t have to worry about spoilers , so some of the takeaways in brief from the book are:-

  • Always judge or predict about Nations within a limited time frame, preferably 5 years, the world is too dynamic for predictions of long run .i.e 10, 20, 30 years ahead.
  • China, will slow down to  <=6% GDP growth rate, and that’s not a bad thing, for a country with 5000$ per capita income , this is acceptable.The richer you grow the slower you become, because that’s just the natural way of things.
  • India, still down in the dumps, crony capitalism(read Corruption) a big hurdle, has to grow infrastructure in a major way,population could be an asset, but should be properly educated and motivated and given opportunists.Having unrealistic growth plans could hurt.50/50 of breaking out.(My interjection :- yeah, fingers crossed alright.)
  • The debate btw Democracy & Authoritarian Regime as a model for ECONOMIC growth is mute and void , Stability and Efficient leadership with Competent implementation are the key to success (My view :- The reds in China are motivated enough, without delivering on economic growth they won’t be able to stay in power ,however much oppressive they may be. Indians argument that we have ‘democracy’  does not & should not be an excuse or counter argument to slow growth. Fast-track reforms and impeccable implementation of the Chinese should be a model for us too.)
  • Brazil,going strong on raw materials and commodity export, %age investment as per GDP is low, poor infrastructure,trying to become a welfare state too early, should invest more inwards specially on infra. A slowing china could hurt Brazil.
  • Mexico, oligarchy prevalent,controlled market, inequality could hurt, breaking monopolies and improving law & order and infra would help.
  • Russia, overly dependent on oil and gas, no major corporate brand on the international forum,tycoons investing money outside the country rather than inside, no trust in the regimes growth agenda, no other major investment sector,long term by the same leader has lead to lethargy in reforms.(My Interjection :- I still like Putin, just because he is a badass, yes i am biased, Sue me!.)
  • South Africa, still enjoying the bliss of getting rid of the ‘Apartheid’ regime,less focus on growth more on welfare activities,slow reforms lead to slow growth despite having a strong financial market.
  • Turkey, could be a breakout nation,Erdogan giving turkey a new Muslim identity, AKP trying to look towards east(and not only to the the EU) a good thing   (My view :- As the book was written in 2011,I could understand this stand, but we know what happened,’Syria’ & a Coup attempt has rattled Turkey, the country despite having a lot of advantages still suffers because the one prerequisite for growth still alludes it,  Stability.)
  • Poland & Czech republic, going strong and going good,took the hard way to comeback, the darling states of Europe,crossing their t’s and dotting their i’s the right way, stalling on the Euro & waiting for things to settle down.Could be a breakout nation.
  • The mess of the Southeast Asia, Thailand :- red shirts (Elites) vs yellow Shirts( Rural) tension,disproportionate growth, Vietnam :-trying to be China, unrealistic, bad management by the communist elites, Philippines :-Corruption,low savings,high consumption,but has potential KPO,BPO could take off in a good way.
  • The Gulf :- The bliss of black Gold propping up the whole region, has to find alternative sources for the economy as well, Oman still has enough oil to last a century, a lot of superficial attempts by the gulf nations without having any major impact.The gulf countries are still secure in the oil cocoon, the competition from ‘Shale’ gas could hurt them.
  • America,still has the advantage of technology,strong R&D and Dollar as the global reserve currency, could still carry on strong and be a breakout nation among the rich countries.
  • Commodity.com, the ever rising prices of commodity can’t go on forever,slowing China and global demand will lead to dropping of prices, this could hurt major raw material and commodity export economies, they will have to make major inroads in domestic consumption and manufacturing finished goods.
  • The third coming of the emerging markets, the economies will grow but detached and more isolated than before, the same wind of globalization won’t carry all the counties like in the past, no global tailwind ,everyone has to ‘Row’ .

No doubt I have missed a lot of points and arguments from the book, leave alone all the number and stats proving the points.Well, you will just have to read it won’t you.

Now to the negative, the book is well researched and well written. The reasoning is logical and easy to follow but the book is now ‘Outdated’ ,it’s 2017, many of the predictions and assumptions of the author didn’t pan out precisely because of his initial argument,its been more than 5 years, the world dynamics has changed, ‘TRUMP’ leads the US ,and talks of ‘Protectionism’ are heard everywhere in the world, the chaos in the middle east is still to be sorted. Just because i picked up this book a bit late i couldn’t give it a higher rating.

But to understand the nuances and arguments of how to actually judge an economy or a breakout country more accurately, i most definitely recommend this to anyone remotely interested in economics.The process followed by Ruchir sharma is to be studied and studied well, his ‘rules of the road’  noted, Politics and Economy are not as isolated as people think, how a capable leader could breakout Nigeria or an inept management doom a previously bright star like Vietnam is to be really understood, one has to look at a lot of aspects and for going that distance , and explaining it in marvelous simplicity i respect the author greatly.

This is a great work though a bit out of sync with the current time but we could hardly fault the author,because as he states in the first chapter itself that:-

As much as we all love the speculative titillation of futurology, no one can forecast the next century with any credibility and, more important, be held accountable for it.”

 

Myth=Mithya: – Decoding the Hindu Enigma

vishwaroopam
Lord Vishnu’s Vishwaroopam Form

“Yada yada hi dharmasya glanirbhavati bharata…..”….the song would start,and i would be at the edge of my seat, this was my favorite part of the show (BR Chopra’s Epic “MAHABHARAT”),it’s starting song, i was 11 and all i wanted to see chanting along as the song progressed, increasing my pitch, was the God with endless faces,it was exciting i would get goosebumps, i didn’t know that that form of ‘Lord Vishnu’was called the “Vishwaroopam”, didn’t know anything besides that it was the coolest thing i had ever seen. My mother tells me that i like mythology and stories from the Indian epic’s so much because she used to watch a lot of them when she was pregnant with me. That like “Abhimanyu”(Son Of Arjuna, an Indian epic hero) who learnt the art of war and ‘Chakravyuh’ in his mother’s womb, I had kind of the same effect.

Whatever the reason, I have always admired myths, and i have always questioned them, my why’s and but’s irritated my parents to no end.My grandfather used to show me an old version of ‘Ramayana’ and ‘Mahabharata’ ,written in Sanskrit,bound by wires on hard horizontal pages, i used to be absolutely stunned seeing him read it flawlessly. Then came the phase of belittling everything,my wonder was replaced with doubt, i had a thousand questions, these couldn’t have happened,Many of them were too fantastic to be true, i felt betrayed, lied to.How could a 10,000 year old civilization actually believe this, were they that stupid, but they invented so much, they endured and survived for so long in such hardships ,HOW could they believe it all. The realization that the purpose of these epics, these hundred thousand stories and myths was to TEACH, to GUIDE, to ENLIGHTEN,to IMPART the philosophies of life, death, creation, civilization, purpose, karma, duty, responsibility,’Dharama’ came much later, and i fell in love with them all over again.Oh the sheer simplicity and brilliance of them all.

mithya

This was my second book by Dr.Pattanaik, The first one that i read “Jaya” was absolutely brilliant.And although ‘Mithya’ predates ‘Jaya‘ ,which could be felt as you read his later works, i found this too to be absolutely marvelous. ‘Sanatan Dharma’ or ‘Hinduism’ is not only the oldest but it is also the most complicated religion there is,was or perhaps ever will be.It is filled with paradoxes and symbolism ,complicated rituals and narratives,mixed with all kinds of superstition that all of it just boggles the mind.In the midst of all this Dr.Pattanaik’s work is a brilliant attempt to find logic in this chaos, to follow the bread crumbs and lead to the crux of it all. I admire this a lot about him.

The book is designed cleverly too,he has used the Hindu trinity to divide the book, ‘Brahma-Saraswati'(Nature of the universe) as the First, ‘Vishnu-Lakshmi'(Cultural codes & Natural laws) as second and ‘Shiva-Shakti'(Soul & Matter)  as third. To anyone jumping right in, the myths might seem randomly all over the place, i would encourage the readers to read the intro and all the tid-bits too, they are not to be skipped. Although a lot of the stories were familiar to me, the associations made and explained, with a lot of visual flow charts and tables were quite refreshing and intriguing. This book deals with a lot of core Hindu ideologies, our idea of Rebirth, Creation, Afterlife, Heaven and Hell, Justice, Samsara, Moksha, Sex, Nature, Culture, Civilized and Uncivilized practices,etc etc.And on almost all accounts i was in agreement with Dr.Pattanaik save few, like his idea of ‘Caste system’ and the fact that if followed as per ‘Family’ legacy there stays harmony in the system,although some do say such a thing, couldn’t it have been the ‘High Caste’ Brahmans who started this just to keep the knowledge to them the select few, because as per my knowledge there is a para in Rig Veda (IX.112.3), where the poet refers to his diverse parentage: “I am a reciter of hymns, my father is a physician and my mother grinds corn with stones. We desire to obtain wealth in various actions.”So, the ‘Varna’ system was initially not meant to be hereditary, though it later became as such, so did a lot of ideas,mutated into something they were not supposed to.So, the stories in Ramayana promoting ‘Varnas'(Castes) as per birth didn’t sit well with me, Dr.Pattanaik should have mentioned the other side of the coin as well.

‘Nature’ And ‘Culture’ are the two pillars of the Vedic ways, often at odds with each other striving for that perfect balance, this idea is thoroughly researched and explained in this book.This was perhaps my favorite part. To explain the difference between ‘Vishnu’ & Samsara and ‘Shiva’ & Sanyasa. That too with his brilliant depictions and illustrations. pattanaik_hari-haraThe relevance of ‘Soul’ and ‘Matter’, of even the color ‘White’ and ‘Red’. There is just so much that you can take away from this book.To anyone remotely interested in Hinduism or Philosophy or Symbolism or even in Myths in general i whole heartily recommend this book. To any guy with an urge to make sense , this is a must.

I rate it 4 out of 5 stars. Goodreads  rating system.

To end with a quote from the book :-

“Within infinite myths lies the eternal truth
Who sees it all?
Varuna has but a thousand eyes,
Indra has a hundred,
You and I, only two.”

The THC:-live love lose learn

the-thc

My first ever ‘giveaways’ book, Received a signed copy from the author on 18th Jan.

I have always had a skeptical view when it comes to love. It always seemed somewhat fantastical, and alas that view hasn’t changed much despite my close brushes with it.That is what seemed to be the theme of this novel, ‘love in the elite world’. And when the author says ‘Uncomfortable topics that are swept under the rug’ he isn’t kidding, the novel gives you things to mull over like,impotence (uh huh, you read that right), addiction (‘Cigarettes’ and that too not focused upon much , i thought there will be junkies shooting up crack all over the place for a moment after that description,but we seemed to have been pardoned that unpleasantness.),  but most importantly relationships and the toll they can take on someone. And oh, lot of sex, i mean Mr Jain could have given Chetan Bhagat a run for his money in some of them i bet.

I was in a dilemma as to what to make of the book, it is essentially a collection of stories narrated by the three main characters in the twilight of their lives, Samar (The man with performance issues), Sanjanaketan (The woman cursed by fate) and Varun (The dude with old man issues and unresolved dude-dude issues) all trying to regain their peace and conquer their demons through a ‘Getaway therapy’ kind of a institute The Total Holistic Center (because the rich can always throw money to cure their heart burns) . Now to be honest, i felt a certain obligation to like this book because i got it for nothing,with an autograph no less. img_20170126_182048

But in good faith i just couldn’t love it all too much,that’s not to say it’s not good, for a second book by any author Mr Jain has done a splendid job, but maybe not my cup of tea.To read about someone else’s life story ,their problems, circumstances gives the reader a reference point, with which consciously or subconsciously he/she will relate and try to draw parallels.Such markers are aplenty in the novel.It makes you sympathize with the characters and hope that they might get closure. Mr Jain has used this aspect well, although the novel do lack a lot of finesse. It shows troubles which might get enacted in a serious version of ‘Sarabhai vs sarabhai’ or maybe an Indian ‘Sex and the city’,couples bored and cheating on each other, bachelorette party with stripers, Gay guy looking for his ‘Beard’  and so on which really doesn’t appeal to me all that much. ‘Varun’ was the only character i might have befriended if he was real among all three to be honest,The father son dynamic narrated in the book is the only thing that i could genuinely appreciate (that too from the son’s perspective). There was just too much that this book could have done without and less of what could have gone right for it. To show the whole curve of loving someone ,then losing that love then learning from that through much sadness and finally finding a way to put the hurt in its place and looking forward to life takes a special kind of tale, and even though i highly appreciate the attempt, it could have been better.

I rate it 2.5 out of 5 stars as per the goodreads rating system.