4/5 Stars Goodreads Rating System
“It’s a bit rich to oppress, enslave, kill, torture, maim people for 200 years and then celebrate the fact that they are democratic at the end of it..” ~Shashi Tharoor
I could have literally kissed the man, Ever Since Mr.Tharoor’s famed Oxford Speech , his popularity has grown by leaps and bounds, and so too my admiration for his views. The view point that “Colonization has actually helped ‘colonized’ people.” has always baffled me, and the argument is made not only by people who have absolutely no idea about what Actual Colonization entailed for the indigenous people of those colonized lands, but also by great scholars, historians and politicians from the previously colonizer countries and also (‘to my utter annoyance & disbelief’) some from the previously colonized ones as well.
This book is the counter argument and to my mind the ONLY argument when it comes to judging the British Raj and its implications on India. Mr. Shashi Tharoor, has taken all the arguments made by the ‘Raj’ Apologists and supporters of colonization and systematically destroyed them all with class and flair. This book is the hard truth , it is blunt in its criticism, well researched and well articulated while presenting its reasoning and absolutely spot on in dismantling the myth of the apparent “Goodness” of the Raj. If you are looking for a detailed account of the British Occupation of India as per its timeline, then this is not it, but this is far far better than mere dates and events, this provides you the detailed account of the EFFECT of British Colonization on India, on its every possible aspect, Economy (Irrefutable logic and Reasoning on this one), Society (‘divide et impera’, the one thing no matter what, i will never forget nor forgive the British for), British law(The oxymoron of the Raj), Development (The Railways! you say,Read the book my dear dear friend), Fair Trade (pfft!), and much more. This will resonate with every Indian and not only US, with every single person out there who has stones enough to stare at the truth with naked eyes be he/she in Africa or Europe. History without context is useless, and Context is what this book provides aplenty. Add to that the brilliantly composed arguments by Mr. Tharoor (Thank God i read this on a kindle, his vocab is formidable.) laced with wit, facts and sarcasm appropriately.
People might call this biased side of an argument, but when there is only one credible argument the question of biases doesn’t even arrive. This is what this book proves. This is how we should see the past with logic, reason, facts , answering the Whys and Hows rather than just the when and wheres. I recommend this to everyone, specially anyone interested in Indian History ,and more so for anyone who is interested in knowing how to argue and refute an argument, Mr.Tharoor has carefully and wisely picked comments and credible reports from history proving his point and disproving the opposite arguments, the book tastes like a debate taking on everyone out there remotely on the opposite side, but this is a taste which is to be had with all its necessary bitterness. Because the most potent and effective medicines are always unpleasant to taste.